Brandy Bread & Butter Pudding

It is getting near the end of Winter and I have been meaning to make a bread and butter pudding.  So when my dear husband said he wanted one of my “spectacular dinners” I decided that this would be on the menu for dessert tonight.

Bread & Butter Pudding

Bread and Butter Pudding may have had humble beginnings but this one is very rich and decadent.  I love all the vanilla and cinnamon flavour in this version and using a fruit loaf instead of plain bread adds another dimension to the pudding.

The quantity given makes a massive pudding that will easily serve 12.  It reheats beautifully the next day, or it can be served cold.


3/4 cup sultanas

¼ cup brandy

1 fruit loaf or tea bun

60 gm soft butter, plus extra for greasing

11 eggs

600 ml pouring cream

500 ml milk

½ cup caster sugar

1 orange, finely grated rind only

2 t/s vanilla bean paste

1 tsp ground cinnamon

440gm pie apples

2 tbsp demerara sugar


Combine sultanas and brandy in a small bowl, microwave for 1 minute and set aside for 1 hour. (This can also be done the day ahead and put in the fridge until needed)

Fruit Loaf

Slice the fruit loaf and butter both sides. Place a layer of the bread on the bottom of a large casserole dish.

pie apple

Combine eggs, cream, milk, caster sugar, orange rind, vanilla and cinnamon in a jug. Whisk vigorously to combine and set aside.

pie apple-2

Scatter ½ the brandied sultanas over the bread layer. Add the pie apples to the pudding, making sure to spread evenly over the bread. Cut remaining bread into cubes and scatter over the apple layer.  Add the remaining sultanas to the pudding.

pie apple-3

Pour cream mixture evenly over the pudding and allow to stand until bread has completely absorbed cream mixture (about 1 hour).

Bread & Butter Pudding-2

Heat oven to 170C. Scatter demerara sugar over pudding and bake until golden and custard is firm (60-70 minutes). Dust with icing sugar and serve with ice-cream.

Bread & Butter Pudding-3