Eyeballs for Halloween
Eyeballs for Halloween

Eyeballs for Halloween

Imagine this, you are a very cute little kindergarten girl, and you open your lunch box to find two googly eyes staring up at you!

Do you scream??

Halloween School Lunch

Halloween School Lunch

I can’t work out whether I am a good mum or a bad one… but four children, at two different schools had that experience today. I packed them my cake pop Halloween Eyeballs for recess. (insert evil laugh).

My poor kids, last week they had Bikini Body Biscuits in their lunchbox and now Eyeballs! Hopefully I don’t cause them any lasting food aversions!

RIP Cake Pops

RIP Cake Pops Eyeballs

…anyway, I have made cake pops in the past and each time I have sworn I will never do it again.  They are not particularly difficult to make but they end up taking a lot of time for a couple of little bites of cake. However, somehow I always find myself back making more… they are just too cute, and they have so much potential to be really special so I just can never resist.

More cakepop Eyeballs in Jelly

Cakepop Eyeballs in Jelly

In a bid to save time and make the cake balls a more uniformed size I decided to try a cake ball tray this time.  When making cake pops using this method the cake is baked in a ball shaped pan, rather than food processing the cake with frosting and rolled into balls. (as in this recipe)

Eyeball in Red Jelly

Eyeball Cake Pops in Red Jelly

Now that I have tried both methods I have come to the conclusion that no method is quicker or easier.  It takes about the same amount of time to do both so it probably comes down to personal preference.

Eyeball in a Glass

Cake Pop Eyeball in a Glass

So how did I make these gruesome snacks?

Eyeball in a Glass

Inside the Cake Pop Eyeball

Firstly I chose to make a batch of my famous Red Velvet Cake, because I feel the inside of an eyeball should always be red. Also my red velvet cake is quite dense and the cake pan manufacturer suggests this style of cake will work best in the pan.

I then poured the batter into the specific cake ball pan using a jug and attached the top cake ball tray as a lid.

Red Velvet Cake Pops

Red Velvet Cake Pops in a tray

The cakes were baked for 15 -20 minutes at 170 degrees. The filling did overflow slightly as the manufacturer predicted so I trimmed the cake from the top pan before I removed the cover.

Allow the cake to cool completely.

Then on to the fun part!

Making Eyeball Cake Pops

  • 200gm white chocolate
  • 18 red jubes
  • 1 tube black wilton icing
  • 1 tube red wilton icing

Line a baking tray with paper and place the cake balls in the freezer on the tray for at least one hour, or until very cold.

Place half the white chocolate in a glass and melt in the microwave for one minute. Stir the chocolate periodically until it is completely melted.

Using either a skewer dip the ball into the chocolate and place back onto the prepared tray. The chocolate should start to set quite quickly.

Once the chocolates have been dipped return the tray to the fridge.

Place 3 or 4 jubes at a time on to a plate and microwave for 10 seconds (experiment with times). The aim is to soften the jube enough so that it can be squashed with the back of a spoon easily. Too long in the microwave will turn the jube into liquid.

Once you have heated and flattened the jube, use a knife to slide under the lolly to remove it from the plate. Place the jube on the eyeball, if necessary use a dot of the remaining white chocolate to secure the sweet in place.

Continue to do this until all the red irises are in place.

Use the red wilton icing to draw veins coming from the pupil.

Use the black wilton icing to add a pupil to the eyes.

Return the eyeballs to the fridge until needed.

Bobbing for cake pop eyeballs

Cake Pops in Red Jelly

Whilst making these delectably delicacies I thought a nice Halloween game might be Bobbing for Eyeballs in red jelly…

What do you think? Do you get into the Halloween Spirit? (no pun intended) Do you dress up in Halloween costumes and trick or treat?

This year I have decided I will dress up as a black cat!  I can’t wait!

Halloween Table Setting

Halloween Table Setting

Gourmet Getaways

About Julie


  1. These look so good, Julie. I bet your children loved them. They must have been thrilled to discover them. I’ve made cake pops and I find them so much work so well done on attempting them again. I was in a store yesterday and they had a silicone cake pop tray that made the complete ball. I hesitated, wondering whether to buy it but moved on! xx

  2. Carlie O'Keefe :

    These are the cutest…yet creepiest treats ever! What a clever idea, they have turned out so well Julie! AND I bet they taste great.

  3. Hehe I love that you put these on red jelly! Well if you were my mum I’d love it! Can’t wait to see your costume 🙂

  4. OMG these eye balls are truly SCARY lol I would be a little skeptical about eating it 😛 but I know it’s completely safe 😀

    SIGHHH I really wanted to make something for Halloween but not sure if i have the time 🙁

  5. These are so, so cool! Loving all your Halloween posts. Such creative, spooky ideas 🙂

  6. It does look and sound time consuming! But guess what, look at the end result! Very crafty!

  7. What a fantastically spooky and delicious treat idea for Halloween! Love this!

  8. How cute!! Perfect for the Halloween weekend. My son would love them. Thank you for sharing with us at the #HomeMattersParty

  9. isch. that is really scary 🙂
    You are welcome to join
    Hugs from Håkan in Sweden


  1. […] Pumpkin Marshmallows | Nutter Butter Bats | Floating Eyeballs […]

  2. […] Purple Monster Snacks  |  Green Slime Punch  |  Monster Mash Pudding Shooters Oreo Truffle Spiders  |  Candy Corn Cupcakes Spooky Spider Cake  |  Candy Corn Mocktails  |  Halloween Candied Popcorn Bloody Cider Drink  |  Candy Corn Cookie Bark Pumpkin Marshmallows  |  Nutter Butter Bats  |  Floating Eyeballs […]

  3. […] Pumpkin Marshmallows | Nutter Butter Bats | Floating Eyeballs […]

  4. […] Purple Monster Snacks | Green Slime Punch | Monster Mash Pudding Shooters Oreo Truffle Spiders | Candy Corn Cupcakes Spooky Spider Cake | Candy Corn Mocktails | Halloween Candied Popcorn Bloody Cider Drink | Candy Corn Cookie Bark Pumpkin Marshmallows | Nutter Butter Bats | Floating Eyeballs […]

  5. […] Pumpkin Marshmallows | Nutter Butter Bats | Floating Eyeballs […]

  6. […] Easy Pepperoni Pizza Bread / Edible Eyeballs for Halloween […]

Speak Your Mind